Dialectical behaviour therapy skills training compared to standard group therapy in borderline personality disorder: A 3-month randomised controlled clinical trial
Introduction
People with borderline personality disorder (BPD) are regular users of emergency services and may often require admission to hospital. They will likely need long psychotherapies and require more medications than other personality disorder or major depression patients (Bender et al., 2006, Lieb et al., 2004). Moreover, BPD is associated with a high prevalence of self-injurious behaviour and an incidence of completed suicide of up to 10%, a rate over 50 times higher than that in the general population. This results in a high consumption of healthcare resources (American Psychiatric Association, 2001, Lieb et al., 2004, Paris, 2002, Stone, 1998) and non-health care costs are even higher (Van Asselt, Dirksen, Arntz, & Severens, 2007).
Various psychosocial interventions have been used in the treatment of BPD and have proved to be effective in randomised clinical trials. Two of these psychological interventions are psychodynamic-oriented treatments, mentalization-based treatment (Bateman and Fonagy, 1999, Bateman and Fonagy, 2001) and transference focused therapy (Clarkin, Kenneth, Lenzenweger, & Kernberg, 2007). The others are variations of cognitive behavioural therapy, such as schema-focused therapy (Giesen-Bloo et al., 2006), cognitive behavioural therapy (Blum et al., 2008, Davidson et al., 2006) and DBT (Koons et al., 2001, Linehan et al., 1991, Linehan et al., 1999, Linehan et al., 2006, Verheul et al., 2003).
The standard DBT procedure (Linehan, 1993a, Linehan, 1993b) includes four modes of intervention: group therapy, individual psychotherapy, phone calls, and consultation team meetings. The group component consists of approximately 2 h a week of skills coaching, and it aims to increase behavioural capabilities. Individual psychotherapy consists of approximately one-hour weekly session whose objective is to improve motivation to change and reduce target problem behaviours. The phone call mode focuses on generalizing skills to daily life, preserving the therapeutic relationship, and learning how to ask for help. The consultation team meetings are attended by all the therapists using DBT and they are held weekly. These meetings aim to provide support for therapists, maintain motivation and adherence to the treatment model, and help to prevent burn out.
Although several studies have introduced modifications in the application of the original design, these adaptations have adjusted DBT to other settings, such as BPD inpatients (Bohus et al., 2004) or to other disorders, such as binge eating disorder (Telch, Agras, & Linehan, 2001).
One study using this standard DBT treatment for BPD (Lindenboim, Comtois, & Linehan, 2007) focused especially on the group component. The authors examined the type and frequency of skills practised by patients receiving one year of standard DBT as a part of a clinical trial (Linehan et al., 2006). This study addressed several questions regarding the skills in standard DBT treatment. In contrast with what is traditionally expected concerning compliance in BPD patients, they reported using some skills regularly, a minimum of at least one skill on most days. The average was more than four skills per day during the one year of treatment. This skills practice increased over the course of treatment, especially in the first months of the therapy. Another finding of interest was that patients preferred to use skills aimed at acceptance rather than change. Although it seems clear that the group mode of DBT in BPD may be partially responsible for the positive outcomes reported in this setting, there is no evidence that DBT-ST treatment is an efficacious intervention without the individual DBT therapy mode. In a nonpublished study, Linehan et al. (Linehan, 1993a) assigned a subgroup of BPD patients receiving non-DBT individual therapy to DBT-ST. The results suggested that adding DBT-ST to non-DBT individual therapy was no more effective than non-DBT individual therapy, and less effective than individual DBT plus DBT-ST treatment. Only one controlled study has been published (Springer, Lohr, Buchtel, & Silk, 1996) to date. It compares content-reduced DBT-ST to a non-psychotherapeutic discussion group. Subjects in both groups significantly improved in most change measures although no significant between-group differences were found. The findings from this study are limited because treatment was short (13 weekdays), the sample characteristics were not homogenous (inpatients with different personality disorders), diagnosis was made by means of a self-reported questionnaire, and considerable modifications were introduced in the standard content of DBT skills training (e.g. the Mindfulness module was not taught).
Skills training is an essential element in DBT treatment in view of the skills deficit underlying BPD. It can be conceptualised as a set of abilities to manage emotional instability and has been adapted to and tested in other diagnoses. In a controlled study that compared an adapted 20-session DBT-ST to waiting list condition in binge eating disorder (Telch et al., 2001), the intervention was associated with a decrease in binge eating behaviour immediately post treatment and at 6-months follow-up. Similarly, DBT-ST plus medication and scheduled telephone coaching have been successfully adapted to treat older depressed patients and have been associated with an improvement in depressive symptoms compared with medication (Lynch, Morse, Mendelson, & Robins, 2003).
Although skills training is thought to play an important role in DBT treatment, is frequently used by BPD patients and have proved to be useful in other disorders such as binge eating disorder or depression, they are not adequately been tested in BPD patients. The aim of this randomised controlled clinical trial was to evaluate whether skills training, one of the four modes of DBT intervention, was sufficient to induce an observable improvement in people with BPD in comparison with standard group therapy (SGT) administered over the same number of hours in a 3-month period.
Section snippets
Participants
A total of 63 patients were included (participants were recruited from outpatient facilities and emergency service). Inclusion criteria consisted of: 1) meeting the DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for BPD as assessed by two semi-structured diagnostic interviews: the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis II Disorders (SCID-II; Gómez-Beneyto et al., 1994) and the Revised Diagnostic Interview for Borderlines (DIB-R; Barrachina et al., 2004); 2) age between 18 and 45 years; 3) no comorbidity
Patient demographics and baseline clinical characteristics
From a total of 114 subjects evaluated, 63 met the inclusion criteria. Patient flow and reason for dropout are presented in Fig. 1. Three patients dropped out of the study during baseline visits. A total of sixty subjects were randomised (1:1). As shown in Table 1, there were no significant differences between the two groups in terms of demographic variables, pharmacological treatment or clinical severity. One patient in the DBT-ST group was excluded from the analysis as she did not attend any
Discussion
In this study we found that DBT-ST was associated with higher retention rates than SGT. Patients treated with DBT-ST had almost a 30% greater probability of completing treatment than the SGT group and only half the number of dropouts. Participant retention procedures in DBT rely mainly on individual therapy and telephone consultation and previous studies have reported good retention rate in DBT interventions (over 70%). By means of DBT-ST intervention over three months we obtained a retention
Acknowledgments
Study supported by grants from the Fondo de Investigación Sanitaria (REF 03/434) and by the Spanish Ministry of Health, Instituto de Salud Carlos III, CIBERSAM.
References (39)
Practice guideline for the treatment of patients with borderline personality disorder
American Journal of Psychiatry
(2001)- et al.
Validation of a Spanish version of the diagnostic interview for borderlines-revised (DIB-R)
Actas Españolas de Psiquiatría
(2004) Impulsiveness and aggression
(1995)- et al.
Effectiveness of partial hospitalization of borderline personality disorder: a randomized controlled trial
American Journal of Psychiatry
(1999) - et al.
Treatment of borderline personality disorder with psychoanalytically oriented partial hospitalization: a 18-month follow-up
American Journal of Psychiatry
(2001) - et al.
Prospective assessment of treatment use by patients with personality disorder
Psychiatric Services
(2006) Strategies for securing commitment to treatment for individuals diagnosed with borderline personality disorder
Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy
(2004)- et al.
Systems training for emotional predictability and problem solving (STEPPS) for outpatients with borderline personality disorder: a randomized controlled trial and 1-year follow-up
American Journal of Psychiatry
(2008) - et al.
Effectiveness of inpatient dialectical behavioral therapy for borderline personality disorder: a controlled trial
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2004) - et al.
An inventory for assessing different kinds of hostility
Journal of Consulting Psychiatry
(1957)
Evaluating three treatments for borderline personality disorder: a multiwave study
American Journal of Psychiatry
The effectiveness of cognitive behavior therapy for borderline personality disorder: results from the borderline personality disorder study of cognitive therapy (BOSCOT) trial
Journal of Personality Disorders
SCL-90: an outpatient psychiatric rating scale: preliminary report
Psychopharmacologic Bulletin
Outpatient psychotherapy for borderline personality disorder: randomized trial of schema-focused therapy vs transference – focused psychotherapy
Archives of General Psychiatry
The diagnosis of personality disorder with a modified version of the SCID-II in a Spanish clinical sample
Journal of Personality Disorders
Clinical global impressions
The assessment of anxiety states by rating
British Journal of Medical Psychology
A rating scale for depression
Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry
Efficacy of dialectical behavior therapy women veterans with borderline personality disorder
Behavioral Therapy
Cited by (168)
Group interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT-G) for borderline personality disorder: A randomized controlled study
2023, Journal of Psychiatric ResearchPharmacologic and non-pharmacologic interventions for emotional lability: A meta-analysis
2023, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral ReviewsThe effect of dialectical behavior therapy on anger and aggressive behavior: A systematic review with meta-analysis
2022, Behaviour Research and TherapyImplementation of a brief online skills group of dialectical behaviour therapy for emotional dysregulation in Latinx: A withdrawal experimental single-case design
2023, Behavioural and Cognitive PsychotherapyDropout from psychological treatment for borderline personality disorder: A multilevel survival meta-analysis
2023, Psychological Medicine