Ten-Year effect of medical and surgical therapy on quality of life: Veterans administration cooperative study of coronary artery surgery

https://doi.org/10.1016/0002-9149(87)90841-1Get rights and content

Abstract

The long-term effect of medical vs surgical therapy on quality of life was evaluated by New York Heart Association functional classification, severity of angina and exercise performance in 427 surviving patients with stable angina at 10 years. Surgically assigned patients had significantly more improvement in functional classification, relief of angina and exercise performance at 1 and 5 years than medically assigned patients. Relative to entry, functional classification was improved in 65% of surgically treated patients at 1 year and in 51 % at 5 years, compared with 45% and 40%, respectively, of medically treated patients. Marked improvement in angina was observed in 49% of surgical patients at 1 year and in 41% at 5 years, vs 12% and 17%, respectively, in medical patients. At 10 years, quality of life was not significantly different in the 2 treatment groups: 52% of surgical patients had an improved functional classification, compared with 46% of medical patients, while 33% of surgical and 37% of medical patients had a marked improvement in angina. Exclusion of medical and surgical nonadherers had little effect on the 1- and 5-year comparisons. The 10-year treatment differences, however, were accentuated when 123 medically assigned patients who later underwent operation and who benefited from it were excluded from the analysis. In surgical patients, a strong association was observed between graft patency and functional class at 1 year, but not at 5 and 10 years. In general, patients with some or all grafts open had more improvement in functional classification than patients with all grafts closed. Thus, the benefit of surgery in relief of symptoms and improvement of exercise performance remained superior to that of medical therapy at 5 years, but at 10 years symptoms increased and exercise tolerance decreased to levels similar to those of the medically treated patients.

References (15)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (0)

This study was supported by the Veterans Administration Cooperative Studies Program, Medical Research Service, Veterans Administration Central Office, Washington, D.C. For a complete listing of all participants, members of the Operations and Executive Committees, Coordinating Center Staff and consultants refer to Circulation 1981;63:1329 (Appendix C).

View full text