Table 1:

Prioritizing nonpharmacologic interventions according to short-run economic impact, social impact and effect on viral transmission

Social impact
LowMediumHigh
Large Rt, effectSmall Rt, effectLarge Rt, effectSmall Rt, effectLarge Rt, effectSmall Rt,effect
Short-run economic impactLow
  • Nonessential border restrictions

  • Enhance detection/surveillance systems

  • Universal mask mandates

  • Requests to follow public health guidelines by leaders

  • Temperature and symptom checks (airport, workplace)

  • Small indoor gathering cancellation

  • Small outdoor gathering cancellation

  • Restaurant/bar crowding restrictions or reduced hours

  • Gym (high occupancy) closures

  • Indoor team sport/dance restrictions

  • Gym (low occupancy) closures

  • Outdoor team sport/dance restrictions

Medium
  • Mass gathering cancellation

  • Government assistance to vulnerable populations for isolation support and pay

  • Nonessential business crowding restrictions

  • Restaurant/bar closures

  • Guaranteed quarantining (e.g., quarantine hotels, daily in-person checks, etc.)

  • Quarantine on entry to country/region

  • Nonessential regional travel restrictions

  • High school and postsecondary school closures

  • Daycare closures

  • Primary school closures

High
  • Essential border restrictions

  • Nonessential high-density retail closure

  • Nonessential manufacturing closures

  • Nonessential low-density retail closures

  • Nonessential low-density manufacturing closures

  • Essential high-density retail closures

  • Essential high-density manufacturing closures

  • Essential low-density retail closures

  • Essential low-density manufacturing closures

  • Public transit closures

  • Note: We used a qualitative approach to categorization.7,8

  • The intent of the table is to identify relative priorities, with the effectiveness of any nonpharmacologic interventions and the magnitude of their economic and social impact being dependent on local contexts. Interventions in green should be introduced earlier; those in grey should be used when aggressive and rapid reductions in case numbers are required.