Skip to main content

Main menu

  • Home
  • Content
    • Current issue
    • Past issues
    • Early releases
    • Collections
    • Sections
    • Blog
    • Infographics & illustrations
    • Podcasts
    • COVID-19 articles
    • Obituary notices
  • Authors & Reviewers
    • Overview for authors
    • Submission guidelines
    • Submit a manuscript
    • Forms
    • Editorial process
    • Editorial policies
    • Peer review process
    • Publication fees
    • Reprint requests
    • Open access
    • Patient engagement
  • Physicians & Subscribers
    • Benefits for Canadian physicians
    • CPD Credits for CMA Members
    • Subscribe to CMAJ Print
    • Subscription prices
    • Obituary notices
  • Alerts
    • Email alerts
    • RSS
  • JAMC
    • À propos
    • Numéro en cours
    • Archives
    • Sections
    • Abonnement
    • Alertes
    • Trousse média 2023
    • Avis de décès
  • CMAJ JOURNALS
    • CMAJ Open
    • CJS
    • JAMC
    • JPN

User menu

Search

  • Advanced search
CMAJ
  • CMAJ JOURNALS
    • CMAJ Open
    • CJS
    • JAMC
    • JPN
CMAJ

Advanced Search

  • Home
  • Content
    • Current issue
    • Past issues
    • Early releases
    • Collections
    • Sections
    • Blog
    • Infographics & illustrations
    • Podcasts
    • COVID-19 articles
    • Obituary notices
  • Authors & Reviewers
    • Overview for authors
    • Submission guidelines
    • Submit a manuscript
    • Forms
    • Editorial process
    • Editorial policies
    • Peer review process
    • Publication fees
    • Reprint requests
    • Open access
    • Patient engagement
  • Physicians & Subscribers
    • Benefits for Canadian physicians
    • CPD Credits for CMA Members
    • Subscribe to CMAJ Print
    • Subscription prices
    • Obituary notices
  • Alerts
    • Email alerts
    • RSS
  • JAMC
    • À propos
    • Numéro en cours
    • Archives
    • Sections
    • Abonnement
    • Alertes
    • Trousse média 2023
    • Avis de décès
  • Visit CMAJ on Facebook
  • Follow CMAJ on Twitter
  • Follow CMAJ on Pinterest
  • Follow CMAJ on Youtube
  • Follow CMAJ on Instagram
The Left Atrium

A cautionary tale

Gordon Warme
CMAJ January 03, 2006 174 (1) 68; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1503/cmaj.051016
Gordon Warme
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • Article
  • Responses
  • Metrics
  • PDF
Loading

Madhouse: a tragic tale of megalomania and modern medicine Andrew Scull Princeton: Yale University Press, 2005 349 pp $37.50 (cloth) ISBN: 0-300-10729-3

More than any other medical specialty, psychiatry is prey to groundless theory; I say this as one who practises in the field. Our patients show no objective signs of abnormality, and despite our rhetoric there is no evidence that any psychiatric disorder is biological. Emotional uproar, tragedy, wild accusation and despair are still the stuff of our everyday work. And yet, being doctors, we hunger for “real” diseases to grapple with, diseases that will yield up biological causes, thus offering hope for specific treatments and definitive cures. From psychobabble, we've moved on to biobabble.

This longing to treat disorders with a physical substrate makes us vulnerable to dangerous nonsense such as insulin coma treatment, lobotomies and theories of chemical imbalance. It is this vulnerability that inspired sociologist Andrew Scull to write this cautionary tale, the strange story of Dr. Henry Cotton.

Cotton was superintendent of the New Jersey State Hospital from 1907 until 1930. During his tenure he became enthralled by the idea that madness was caused by hidden foci of infection — an idea that, although on its deathbed, was still around when I was a medical student. Diligent eradication of such infections would, Cotton thought, wipe out the scourge of mental illness. He had the support of his profession, especially his mentor, Adolf Meyer, chief of psychiatry at Johns Hopkins Medical School.

Cotton's convictions led him to radical intervention: he treated all patients by surgically removing every potential site of infection. Teeth, tonsils and the colon were his favourites, but the spleen, uterus and bladder were also suspect. His surgical death rate was scandalously high — hundreds died —and, contrary to his own claims, cures were uncommon.

Adolf Meyer was commissioned to investigate, and assigned this job to his most brilliant student, Phyllis Greenacre. Her findings were devastating. It is a sad fact that Adolf Meyer suppressed her report: medical solidarity had gone mad.

How is it that the medical establishment could have been so easily fooled? Think of bloodletting, purges, diets, mountain air, mustard plasters, magnetism, sexual abstinence — you name it, someone has recommended it. In this age of evidence-based medicine, we are presumably less vulnerable — except in psychiatry. Because we have nothing objective to study and measure, we rely on patients' opinions of whether our treatments work. But even a questionnaire (a trick that makes us think that, like real doctors, we have a “test”) leaves us at the mercy of the placebo effect. We can't produce objective proof that even our most successfully propagandized treatment, antidepressants, does anything.

This is what befuddled Henry Cotton. Some patients probably improved, but time showed he had cured no one. His discouraging long-term outcomes are echoed by modern studies that conclude that, in the long term, schizophrenic patients treated with neuroleptics do no better than those who don't get them. Never mind that many studies are flawed: if the results with and without neuroleptics aren't different enough to be easily distinguished, we know the treatment isn't doing much. But, in the short term, because they suppress unattractive behaviour, treatment with neuroleptics makes physicians and family members feel more comfortable; we feel we are doing something, even though the long- term effects should cause us disquiet.

When we are too enthusiastic, we doctors make errors: in a state of furor therapeuticus, as a precautionary measure, Henry Cotton removed teeth from members of his own family. Curb your enthusiasm, I say. Medical sobriety trumps medical passion every time. Treat yourself to Andrew Scull's new book, a fast-paced thriller that reminds us that fervour can lead us astray.

Gordon Warme Centre for Addiction and Mental Health Toronto, Ont.

PreviousNext
Back to top

In this issue

Canadian Medical Association Journal: 174 (1)
CMAJ
Vol. 174, Issue 1
3 Jan 2006
  • Table of Contents
  • Index by author
  • Canadian Adverse Reaction Newsletter (117-124)

Article tools

Respond to this article
Print
Download PDF
Article Alerts
To sign up for email alerts or to access your current email alerts, enter your email address below:
Email Article

Thank you for your interest in spreading the word on CMAJ.

NOTE: We only request your email address so that the person you are recommending the page to knows that you wanted them to see it, and that it is not junk mail. We do not capture any email address.

Enter multiple addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
A cautionary tale
(Your Name) has sent you a message from CMAJ
(Your Name) thought you would like to see the CMAJ web site.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Citation Tools
A cautionary tale
Gordon Warme
CMAJ Jan 2006, 174 (1) 68; DOI: 10.1503/cmaj.051016

Citation Manager Formats

  • BibTeX
  • Bookends
  • EasyBib
  • EndNote (tagged)
  • EndNote 8 (xml)
  • Medlars
  • Mendeley
  • Papers
  • RefWorks Tagged
  • Ref Manager
  • RIS
  • Zotero
‍ Request Permissions
Share
A cautionary tale
Gordon Warme
CMAJ Jan 2006, 174 (1) 68; DOI: 10.1503/cmaj.051016
Digg logo Reddit logo Twitter logo Facebook logo Google logo Mendeley logo
  • Tweet Widget
  • Facebook Like

Jump to section

  • Article
  • Responses
  • Metrics
  • PDF

Related Articles

  • No related articles found.
  • Google Scholar

Cited By...

  • No citing articles found.
  • Google Scholar

More in this TOC Section

  • Chronicles of a cardiologist in Canada's North
  • Rethinking randomized controlled trials
  • The impetus to cure
Show more The Left Atrium

Similar Articles

 

View Latest Classified Ads

Content

  • Current issue
  • Past issues
  • Collections
  • Sections
  • Blog
  • Podcasts
  • Alerts
  • RSS
  • Early releases

Information for

  • Advertisers
  • Authors
  • Reviewers
  • CMA Members
  • CPD credits
  • Media
  • Reprint requests
  • Subscribers

About

  • General Information
  • Journal staff
  • Editorial Board
  • Advisory Panels
  • Governance Council
  • Journal Oversight
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Copyright and Permissions
CMAJ Group

Copyright 2023, CMA Impact Inc. or its licensors. All rights reserved. ISSN 1488-2329 (e) 0820-3946 (p)

All editorial matter in CMAJ represents the opinions of the authors and not necessarily those of the Canadian Medical Association or its subsidiaries.

To receive any of these resources in an accessible format, please contact us at CMAJ Group, 500-1410 Blair Towers Place, Ottawa ON, K1J 9B9; p: 1-888-855-2555; e: cmajgroup@cmaj.ca

CMA Civility, Accessibility, Privacy

 

Powered by HighWire