The differential effects of insulin sensitivity and adiposity on androgen concentrations in women with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) are unclear. To address this issue, we divided 43 overweight women into 4 groups based on both their clinical classification (PCOS or normal) and whether they were insulin resistant (IR) or insulin sensitive (IS) by their steady-state plasma glucose concentrations. Total testosterone concentrations were significantly increased as a function of both clinical classification (PCOS vs normal, P < .0001) and steady-state plasma glucose concentration (IR vs IS, P = .002). Mean testosterone concentrations were higher in PCOS-IR compared with PCOS-IS, normal-IR, or normal-IS women (P < .005). In addition, there was a statistically significant interaction (P = .03) between clinical classification (PCOS vs normal) and insulin sensitivity (IR vs IS) for testosterone concentrations. In contrast, androstenedione concentrations were higher in women with PCOS (P = .001), irrespective of whether they were IR or IS (P = .31); and no interaction between clinical classification and insulin sensitivity was discerned (P = .34). These results indicate that both PCOS and insulin resistance independently contributed to increased total testosterone concentrations within a group of overweight/obese women. These findings are consistent with the hypothesis that the ovaries of women with PCOS are hypersensitive to the ability of insulin to increase testosterone production and that the more insulin resistant the patient, the higher the testosterone concentration. In contrast, androstenedione concentrations seem to be independent of differences in insulin resistance. Our findings emphasize the need to increase understanding of the factors that modulate ovarian androgen secretion.