Original Articles
A collaborative research utilization approach to evaluate the effects of pain management standards on patient outcomes

https://doi.org/10.1053/jpnu.2000.4593Get rights and content

Abstract

The generation of research-based knowledge is incomplete unless it reaches clinicians at the point of care. Despite major advances in clinical research related to pain management, inadequate pain relief has become a significant quality issue in hospitalized patients, which has created an imperative for research-based pain management. Using a collaborative research utilization model, multidisciplinary academic scientists were paired with clinicians and undergraduate and graduate students to form a partnership that (1) examined the research base in pain management, (2) generated a research-based standard for pain management, and (3) evaluated the effect of that standard on four patient outcome variables in a 230-bed teaching hospital. A 2-group, pretest-intervention-posttest, quasi-experimental clinical trial composed of 173 surgical and oncology subjects was conducted. Subjects whose caregiver used the new standard had less pain during their hospital stay, less interference by pain with quality-of-life indicators, and greater satisfaction with the interventions used as well as caregiver responsiveness to their pain. Interestingly, each of these improvements decreased after their discharge home. These results strongly suggest the need for better postdischarge preparation for pain management and for further development and testing of pain management standards in postdischarge settings. They also provide the basis for extending the model to address other situations in which there is a lag between the promising results of empirical research and their integration into practice. J Prof Nurs 16:240-250, 2000.

References (0)

Cited by (26)

  • Does adherence to national comprehensive cancer network guidelines improve pain-related outcomes? An evaluation of inpatient cancer pain management at an academic medical center

    2014, Journal of Pain and Symptom Management
    Citation Excerpt :

    Cancer pain continues to be an under-recognized source of patient suffering and dissatisfaction within health care systems.1 Pain is one of the most common and feared symptoms of cancer, experienced by 30–50% of patients with cancer receiving treatment and 70–90% of patients with advanced disease.2,3 Much of our knowledge about the prevalence and management of cancer pain was reported in the seminal article by Cleeland et al.4 Their report showed that 67% of outpatient oncology patients with advanced cancer used analgesics; however, 42% of these patients were unable to attain analgesia because of inadequate prescribing.

  • Pain in hospitalized children: Effect of a multidimensional knowledge translation strategy on pain process and clinical outcomes

    2014, Pain
    Citation Excerpt :

    Poorly managed procedural pain in infants can alter pain processing and perception [4,46] and can negatively impact physiological, social and neurocognitive developmental outcomes [18]. Conversely, effective pain management strategies are associated with more rapid and full recoveries and decreased costs to the health care system [10]. The undertreatment of procedural pain in hospitalized children remains a major concern despite exponential growth in pain research, effective evidence-based pain management strategies, validated pain assessment tools, and evidence-based pain standards and guidelines [1,2,51,54,56].

  • Epidemiology and management of painful procedures in children in Canadian hospitals

    2011, CMAJ. Canadian Medical Association Journal
    Citation Excerpt :

    The reporting of precise unadjusted p values allows for the degree of significance to be evaluated within the context of all tests examined. Decreases in the number of painful procedures performed and improvements in pain management associated with procedures are essential to relieve pain and suffering and to capitalize on the associated benefits for patients and the decreased use of health care resources.28 Careful consideration of the need for painful procedures for pediatric inpatients and the importance of ensuring a balanced array of pharmacologic and nonpharmacologic interventions should be emphasized during health care professionals' training.

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text