Prehospital Advanced Life Support for Major Trauma: Critical Need for Clinical Trials☆,☆☆,★
Section snippets
INTRODUCTION
Since the inception of prehospital care there has been an ongoing debate over the use of Advanced Life Support (ALS) measures in the out-of-hospital management of trauma victims. The debate centers around the assumption that the benefit of the various procedures available to the ALS provider (ie, intravenous access and intubation) must be weighed against the delay to definitive care that would result from a prolonged on-scene interval (OSI). There is no doubt that trauma system development has
THE ARGUMENT AGAINST ON-SCENE ALS IN TRAUMA CARE
Most authors who oppose the use of ALS for trauma care at the scene use the rationale that it wastes precious time that could be used in rapidly moving the patient to “definitive care.” A review of these publications reveals many of them are little more than editorials based on indirect data, theoretical arguments, and literature reviews from other editorials (Table 1).Author Prospective Controls Randomized Empty Cell
THE ARGUMENT FOR PREHOSPITAL ALS IN TRAUMA CARE
Some experts believe that a significant number of trauma patients deteriorate or die en route to the hospital from physiologic abnormalities that could potentially be improved by prehospital ALS. They believe that, by adding prehospital ALS, the victims have an improved likelihood of prehospital survival so that they have a chance to benefit from “definitive care.” Numerous investigations seem to support this concept (Table 2).
TIME INTERVAL FROM INJURY TO DEFINITIVE CARE
There is no objective proof that the primary determinant of outcome for the trauma patient is the time interval from injury to the operating room. The “studies” that support this relationship are flawed and nearly all are retrospective.
A series of studies by Bickell et al20, 21, 22 randomly assigned trauma patients into groups that would, or would not, receive the pneumatic antishock garment. Numerous aspects of the data were analyzed including time intervals. No association was found between
THE IMPACT OF ON-SCENE INTERVAL ON TRAUMA OUTCOME
Clearly, no association between the total prehospital interval and outcome has been established. Thus it is puzzling that there has been such a tremendous “brouhaha” in the literature regarding the “impact” of the OSI…since it is merely a portion of the total prehospital interval. This is especially surprising since OSI represents only a small percentage of time elapsed from injury to the operating room. The actual time sequence that exists for the trauma patient includes 911 notification,
THE EFFECT OF ALS ON PREHOSPITAL TIME INTERVALS
One of the most consistent historical arguments against the use of on-scene ALS care (especially establishing intravenous access) has been the belief that on-scene intravenous access attempts “take a long time” and will, necessarily, cause a significant delay in evacuation to definitive care. A classic example of this was revealed in a study by Smith et al.26 They retrospectively reviewed 52 consecutive trauma patients with blood pressures less than 100 mm Hg at the scene or on arrival at the
References (40)
- et al.
Traumatic cardiac arrest: Scope of paramedic services
Ann Emerg Med
(1985) - et al.
A controlled trial of prehospital advanced life support in trauma
Ann Emerg Med
(1988) - et al.
Prehospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation of the critically injured patient
Am J Surg
(1984) - et al.
Load and go versus stay and play: Analysis of prehospital IV fluid therapy by computer simulation
Ann Emerg Med
(1990) - et al.
Effect of antishock trousers on the trauma score: A prospective analysis in the urban setting
Ann Emerg Med
(1985) - et al.
Randomized trial of pneumatic antishock garments in the prehospital management of penetrating abdominal injuries
Ann Emerg Med
(1987) - et al.
The relationship between total prehospital time and outcome in hypotensive patients with penetrating trauma
Ann Emerg Med
(1987) - et al.
Critical care air transportation of the severely injured: Does long distance transport adversely affect survival?
Ann Emerg Med
(1990) - et al.
Prospective evaluation of a new model for evaluating emergency medical services systems by in-field observation of specific time intervals in prehospital care
Ann Emerg Med
(1993) - et al.
Evaluation of resuscitation from cardiopulmonary arrest by paramedics
Ann Emerg Med
(1980)
Factors contributing to paramedic on-scene time during evaluation and management of blunt trauma
Am J Emerg Med
Prehospital intravenous line placement: A prospective study
Ann Emerg Med
Prehospital advanced life support for critical blunt trauma victims
Ann Emerg Med
Prehospital advanced trauma life support for penetrating cardiac wounds
Ann Emerg Med
A prospective in-field comparison of intravenous line placement by urban and non-urban emergency medical services personnel
Ann Emerg Med
The impact of injury severity and prehospital procedures on scene time in victims of major trauma
Ann Emerg Med
The Ontario Prehospital ALS Project (OPALS): Rationale and methodology for cardiac arrest patients
Ann Emerg Med
An analysis of prehospital care of blunt trauma
J Trauma
Prehospital advanced life support: Benefits in trauma
J Trauma
The effects of prehospital trauma care on survival from a 50-meter fall
J Trauma
Cited by (50)
Statement of severe trauma management in France; teachings of the FIRST study
2013, Annales Francaises d'Anesthesie et de ReanimationCitation Excerpt :Hence, several studies compared these entities in the trauma field and support the concept of “the faster, the better”. The pre-hospital medical-staffed teams would lengthen the on-scene time because more aggressive care would be provided to the patient before his transport to the hospital [2]. However, most of these studies describing trauma implying a haemorragic shock underline the concept of golden hour but caution must be taken for the extension of this concept for blunt trauma patients without hemorrhagic mechanism [3].
Balancing the potential risks and benefits of out-of-hospital intubation in traumatic brain injury: The intubation/hyperventilation effect
2012, Annals of Emergency MedicineCitation Excerpt :In early traumatic brain injury care, intubation may be associated with worsened secondary injury. Some reports have implicated out-of-hospital intubation as a factor associated with negative outcomes.5,15-20 Other investigations have demonstrated no difference or improved outcomes with field intubation.13,14,17,21-23
The pending loss of advanced life support paramedics in South Africa
2012, African Journal of Emergency MedicineCitation Excerpt :The role and subsequent value of pre-hospital advanced life support (ALS) has been a growing concern of emergency medical services (EMS) and government for many years.1
Prognostic factors in chest traumas: A prospective study of 500 patients
2010, Cirugia EspanolaBlunt Thoracic Trauma
2008, Mechanical Ventilation: Clinical Applications and PathophysiologyA Comprehensive Framework for Determining the Cost of an Emergency Medical Services System
2007, Annals of Emergency Medicine
- ☆
From the Arizona Emergency Medicine Research Center, Health Services Research Program, Section of Emergency Medicine, Department of Surgery, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ.
- ☆☆
Reprint no. 47/1/93131
- ★
Reprints not available from the authors.