Table 1:

Description of analyzed treatment comparisons

StudyComparison*Admission outcomeType of condition or disease
Poole et al.8Mucolytic agents for chronic bronchitis or COPDAdmissionRespiratory
Walters et al.9Systemic corticosteroids for acute exacerbations of COPDCause-specific readmissionRespiratory
Barr et al.10Tiotropium v. ipratropium, salmeterol or placebo for stable COPDCause-specific admissionRespiratory
Ducharme et al.11Addition of long-acting β2-agonists to inhaled corticosteroids for chronic asthma (adults and children)Cause-specific admissionRespiratory
Cates et al.12Salmeterol for chronic asthma (adults and children)AdmissionRespiratory
Nannini et al.13Combined fluticasone + salmeterol v. fluticasone for COPDCause-specific admissionRespiratory
Nannini et al.14Combined fluticasone + salmeterol v. salmeterol for COPDCause-specific admissionRespiratory
Spencer et al.15Long-acting β2-agonists v. inhaled corticosteroids for COPDCause-specific admissionRespiratory
Cates et al.16Combined budesonide + formoterol v. terbutaline to relieve chronic asthmaCause-specific admissionRespiratory
Cates et al.17Single inhaler therapy v. current best practice for chronic asthma (adults and children)Cause-specific admissionRespiratory
Welsh et al.18Formoterol v. short-acting β2-agonists to relieve asthma (adults and children)Cause-specific admissionRespiratory
Karner et al.19Tiotropium + inhaled corticosteroid + long-acting β2-agonist v. tiotropium + placebo for COPDAdmissionRespiratory
Abba et al.20Albendazole in neurocysticercosis (adults and children)AdmissionInfectious
Walters et al.21Pneumococcal vaccine in COPDAdmissionInfectious
Poole et al.22Influenca vaccine in COPDAdmissionInfectious
Soares-Weiser et al.23Rotavirus vaccination for preventing diarrhea (children)Cause-specific admissionInfectious
Grimwade et al.24Cotrimoxazole prophylaxis for opportunistic infections in HIVAdmissionInfectious
Grimwade et al.25Cotrimoxazole prophylaxis for opportunistic infections in HIV (children)AdmissionInfectious
Meremikwu et al.26Chemoprophylaxis and intermittent treatment for preventing malaria (children)AdmissionInfectious
Kabra et al.27Chloramphenicol v. penicillin + gentamicin for community-acquired pneumonia (children)ReadmissionInfectious
Lucero et al.28Pneumococcal conjugate vaccination v. placebo or other vaccination (children)AdmissionInfectious
Thomas et al.29Offer of influenza vaccine for health care workers who work with older adultsAdmissionInfectious
Graves et al.30SPf66 vaccine for preventing malaria (children)AdmissionInfectious
Okebe et al.31 comparison AIron supplements + antimalarial treatment in malaria-endemic areas (children)AdmissionInfectious
Okebe et al.31 comparison BIron supplements + folic acid in malaria-endemic areas (children)AdmissionInfectious
Okebe et al.31 comparison CIron supplements for proven malaria (children)AdmissionInfectious
Okebe et al.31 comparison DIron supplements in malaria-endemic areas (children)AdmissionInfectious
Soares-Weiser et al.32 comparison ARotaTeq to prevent rotavirus diarrhea (children)Cause-specific admissionInfectious
Soares-Weiser et al.32 comparison BRotarix to prevent rotavirus diarrhea (children)Cause-specific admissionInfectious
Humphreys et al.33 comparison ACotrimoxazole to prevent diarrhea in children with HIV or exposure to maternal HIVCause-specific admissionInfectious
Humphreys et al.33 comparison BVitamin A to prevent diarrhea in children with HIVCause-specific admissionInfectious
Phelps et al.34d-Penicillamine to prevent retinopathy of prematurity in infants born pretermReadmissionNeonatal
Halliday et al.35Late postnatal corticosteroids for chronic lung disease in infants born pretermReadmissionNeonatal
Halliday et al.36Early postnatal corticosteroids to prevent chronic lung disease in infants born pretermReadmissionNeonatal
Stewart et al.37Thiazide with spironolactone in infants born preterm with (or developing) chronic lung diseaseCause-specific readmissionNeonatal
Ryan et al.38Inhaled antipseudomonal antibiotic for long-term therapy in cystic fibrosis (adults and children)AdmissionInfectious
Roderick et al.39Bicarbonate for correction of chronic metabolic acidosis in chronic kidney diseaseAdmissionOther
Baldwin et al.40Dietary advice plus nutritional supplements v. dietary advice for disease-related malnutritionAdmission or ReadmissionOther
Cohen et al.41Antibiotic prophylaxis for spontaneous bacterial peritonitis in cirrhosis with ascites without gastrointestinal bleedingReadmissionInfectious
Komossa et al.42Olanzapine v. clozapine for schizophreniaReadmissionOther
Ngo et al.43Erythropoiesis-stimulating agents for anemia in chronic heart failureCause-specific admissionOther
Baumeister et al.44Pharmacological interventions for depression in coronary artery diseaseAdmissionOther
Imdad et al.45Vitamin A for preventing morbidity and death (children)AdmissionOther
Hofmeyr et al.46Transcervical amnioinfusion for intrapartum umbilical cord compressionAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Duley et al.47Diazepam v. magnesium sulfate for eclampsiaAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Duley et al.48Phenytoin v. magnesium sulfate for eclampsiaAdmissionMaternal–fetal
King et al.49Prophylactic antibiotics for inhibiting preterm labour with intact membranesAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Makrides et al.50Magnesium supplementation in pregnancyAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Abalos et al.51 comparison AAny antihypertensive agent for mild to moderate hypertension in pregnancyAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Abalos et al.51 comparison BAny antihypertensive agent v. methyldopa for mild to moderate hypertension in pregnancyAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Alfirevic et al.52Oxytocin for cervical ripening and induction of labourAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Dodd et al.53Betamimetics for maintenance therapy after threatened preterm labourAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Crowther et al.54Repeat doses v. single course of prenatal corticosteroids for women at risk of preterm birthAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Rumbold et al.55Any vitamin supplementation to prevent miscarriageAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Rumbold et al.56Any antioxidants to prevent preeclampsiaAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Roberts et al.57Antenatal corticosteroids to accelerate fetal lung maturation for women at risk of preterm birthAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Peña-Rosas et al.58Iron supplementation in pregnancyAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Buppasiri et al.59Calcium supplementation (other than to prevent or treat hypertension) in pregnancyAdmissionMaternal–fetal
Hood et al.60Digitalis for congestive heart failure in patients in sinus rhythmAdmissionCardiovascular
Martin-Rendon et al.61Stem cell treatment for acute myocardial infarctionReadmissionCardiovascular
Martí-Carvajal et al.62Homocysteine lowering to prevent cardiovascular eventsCause-specific admissionCardiovascular
  • Note: COPD = chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

  • * Unless stated otherwise, patients were adults and comparators were placebo or no treatment. In maternal–fetal conditions, outcomes were assessed in the newborns.

  • This is the only comparison that had cause-specific mortality outcomes.